Scarce corn idles ethanol plants
Argus Leader • Posted: Wednesday, February 13, 2013
The Renewable Fuels Association, an ethanol industry trade group, provided data to The Associated Press showing that 20 of the nation’s 211 ethanol plants have ceased production during the past year, including five in January. Most remain open, with workers spending time performing maintenance-type tasks. But ethanol production probably won’t resume until after this year’s corn is harvested in late August or September.
Industry experts don’t expect a shortage — millions of barrels are stockpiled and the remaining 191 plants are producing. Yet concern is mounting .
“There’s a lot of anxiety in the industry right now about the drought and a lot of folks watching the weather and hoping and praying this drought is going to break,” said Geoff Cooper, vice president for research and analysis for the Renewable Fuels Association.
“If we get back to a normal pattern and normal corn crop, then I think the industry is in good shape,” Cooper said. “But if this drought persists and it has the same effect on this coming corn crop, then we’ve got a problem.”
America’s ethanol industry has taken off in the past decade. Ethanol plants in 28 states produce more than 13 billion gallons of ethanol each year, Cooper said. By comparison, in 2002, the industry produced 2.1 billion gallons. Today, roughly 10 percent of the U.S. gasoline supply is made up of the biofuel.
Six of the 20 ethanol plants that stopped production are in Nebraska, two in Indiana, and two in Minnesota. Ten states have seen one plant affected. Cooper said the 20 plants employ about 1,000 workers combined, but the number laid off is unknown.
Valero Energy Corp., idled three plants last year, including one in Nebraska.
Five plants ceased production in January alone, including two more in Nebraska.
Officials at the nation’s leading ethanol makers — Archer Daniels Midland and Poet — declined to speculate about whether additional plants will close. Poet spokesman Matt Merritt of Sioux Falls said producing ethanol at Poet’s biorefining plant in Macon, Mo., which closed in January, became cost-prohibitive. Not enough Missouri corn was available, and shipping it in simply was too expensive.
About 95 percent of U.S. ethanol is made from corn. The National Corn Growers Association estimates that 39 percent of the U.S. corn crop is used in ethanol production.
In South Dakota, ethanol production is the No. 1 use for corn, said Lisa Richardson, executive director of the South Dakota Corn Growers Association. The state has 15 ethanol plants that use 320 million bushels of corn a year.
Corn producers had high hopes going into last year. Record harvests were predicted.
Then the weather dried up. Even though more acres were planted last year than in 2011, 13 percent less corn was harvested.
In South Dakota, it depended on location. The year finished out with a total of 500 million bushels produced, but while the northeastern part of the state had a great year, the southeast took a hit, Richardson said.
Availability of locally produced corn is vital for ethanol plants since having it shipped in is considered too expensive. To make matters worse, the drought hit hardest in many of the top corn-growing states.
The production stoppages are cutting into ethanol production. The 770,000 gallons per day produced in the last full week of January were the fewest since the U.S. Energy Information Administration began tracking weekly data in June 2010.
That’s not much of an issue for consumers, at least for now, because there are plenty of stockpiles of ethanol. Purdue University agriculture economist Chris Hurt said the nation has more than 20 million barrels of ethanol in stock, slightly more than a year ago, largely because Americans are driving less and driving more fuel-efficient cars. Cooper said, though, that stockpiles are expected to dwindle in the spring and summer as demand picks up and plants remain idled.
Hurt said the ethanol industry needs an end to the drought, a strong corn crop and a drop in corn prices. Corn futures were $5.51 a bushel in May, before the drought’s impact took hold. Prices rose to a peak of $8.34 per bushel in August and were $7.46 per bushel last week.
“I cannot see any profitability in this industry until we get lower corn prices, and it’s going to take a reasonable-sized U.S. crop,” Hurt said.
Richardson said that while drought has had an effect, the lack of a market for ethanol is the larger issue.
“We need a good corn crop but more importantly they just need market access,” she said. Long term, the market is limited, because people are driving less and E15 has not had the market access that it needs, she said.
“We could have a bin-buster or we could have another drought. Who knows, but I think the predictions are a lot of corn being planted this spring.”
Cooper said most of the idled plants expect to restart production — just not anytime soon. Corn is expected to remain scarce and expensive at least until the 2013 crop is harvested, starting in late August and into September. Cooper believes ethanol production won’t resume at most plants until then.
For now, many of the plants remain open with workers doing maintenance or helping to modernize the facilities while they wait for production to resume, Cooper said.
Only one of the closed production facilities, an ADM plant in Wallhalla, N.D., might be closed for good, Cooper said.
“Generally, the industry is optimistic,” Cooper said. “We’re just going through a rough patch here.”
Not everyone associated with the industry is that optimistic.
Brian Baalman farms near Menlo, Kansas, typically growing 8,000 acres of corn each year. Last year’s crop was about one-third of that. This year, he may plant only the one-third of his acreage where irrigation is available this summer.
Like many growers, Baalman has a direct interest in ethanol. He is on the board of Western Plans Energy in Oakley, Kansas, and has stock in seven ethanol plants. He said near-record prices for corn, driven up by the drought-fueled shortage, are making ethanol production costs too high.
“We are burning up all our excess cash just to stay running at a reduced rate to keep people working and keep the people there, keep the lights on, so to speak,” Baalman said. “It’s very tough right now.”
“A lot of these ethanol plants aren’t going to make it,” Baalman said.